Journal of engineering and construction management

Peer Review Process

This flowchart illustrates the peer review process in this journal, highlighting the steps from manuscript submission to publication. The peer review process at this journal is carried out in an anonymous manner, using a double-blind method. 

Below is a detailed explanation of each step:

1. Author Submission

The process begins when the author submits their manuscript to the journal for consideration.

2. Technical Editor Review

The technical editor conducts an initial review to ensure the manuscript meets basic submission requirements, such as:

• Relevance to the journal’s scope
• Correct formatting
• Proper paper structure
• Appropriate keywords
• Typographical accuracy

Decision Point: Is the manuscript acceptable?

• If the manuscript meets all requirements, it proceeds to the next stage.
• If not, it is returned to the author with a request for revisions and re-submission.

3. Editor Review

The manuscript is forwarded to the editor for further evaluation regarding its suitability for peer review.

Decision Point: Is the manuscript acceptable?

• If the editor deems the manuscript unsuitable for peer review, it is rejected.
• If the manuscript is deemed suitable, it moves forward in the process.

4. Reviewer Selection

Reviewers are suggested based on their expertise and relevance to the manuscript’s subject matter.

5. Manuscript Sent to Reviewers

The manuscript is sent to the selected peer reviewers for a detailed assessment.

6. Reviewers’ Feedback

The reviewers provide feedback, which may include:

• General comments
• Suggestions for revisions or additional questions

7. Author Revisions

Based on the feedback from the reviewers, the manuscript is returned to the author for revisions. The author is expected to address specific comments and make necessary changes.

8. Revised Manuscript Submission

The author submits the revised manuscript, incorporating the reviewers’ suggestions and comments.

9. Final Editorial Decision

After reviewing the revised manuscript, the editor makes a final decision:

• Accept without comments: The manuscript is ready for publication.
• Accept with comments: Minor issues remain, but the manuscript can proceed after minor revisions.
• Reject: The manuscript is unsuitable for publication.

10. Publication Procedures

Once the manuscript is accepted, it moves into the publication phase, which includes final formatting, copyediting, and preparation for release.